Easter Lamb Cake, The Next Generation

Editor’s Note: We’re so excited to share with you a heartwarming family tradition. A few years ago, Galen Lehman shared how making a lamb cake was part of his family’s Easter celebration. Today his daughter, Lindsay, is continuing the tradition with her own daughter. Learn step-by-step how to make this cake for your family!

This lamb cake has been a staple at Easter dessert for as long back as I can remember, started by my grandma. I am so grateful that it is a tradition my mother continued after my grandma passed away, and I’m so excited that I now get to continue it with my own daughter.

Somethings have changed throughout the years, like using a new lamb mold by Wilson instead of my grandma’s thick cast-iron mold as there were too many grandchildren who wanted the beloved old one. Another change was more out of necessity though… While my grandmother‘s hand written recipe was full of love, memories, and good intentions, it certainly would not have won any awards for taste.

lamb cake pan
This lamb-shaped pan is the first step in making this adorable Easter cake. You can find it at Lehmans.com

In fact, I have many memories of my aunts and uncles making jokes about how the lamb cake was so cute, but was much better suited for decoration. However, since making some changes to the recipe, and finding that any dense cake recipe will do, the lamb cake is a favorite once again not just for appearance, but for taste as well!

How to Make Your Own Easter Lamb Cake

Here’s how I’m making it for my family.

Other than making sure to use a dense recipe, the most important thing is to grease your mold well. We have always greased ours with Crisco or butter and then also dusted it with flour. When filling the cake mold you will only use about 2/3 of the batter. We like to use the rest of the batter for muffins or cupcakes!

Ingredients:

  • 1 box devils food cake mix
  • 1 small box of instant chocolate pudding
  • 4 eggs
  • 1 1/4 cups water
  • 1/2 cup vegetable oil
  • Chocolate chips, to taste

Simply mix all of your ingredients well, then pour to the rim of the greased mold’s bottom piece. We have found that laying toothpicks alongside the neck helps to provide support. I wouldn’t recommend skipping this step unless you want your lambs head to topple off, but make sure to warn your guests that there are toothpicks there!

pan filled with batter
Time to bake!

I also used twine to secure the mold while baking, but I’ve skipped this step before without a problem.

pan wrapped in twine
Here’s the pan wrapped in twine.

The cake will need to bake between 45 and 60 minutes depending on your oven settings. After 45 minutes, it is safe to remove the top mold, and use a toothpick to check the doneness. The cake will maintain its shape while it finishes baking.

unfrosted lamb cake
Now that the cake is baked, it’s time to decorate!

For decorations, we have always frosted the cake and then patted coconut onto the icing to add texture to the fleece. We also dropped some food dye into shredded coconut to die it green and add edible grass around the lamb.

frosted lamb cake
After you frost, add some coconut for texture.

Jellybeans are a festive addition and a ribbon around the lamb’s neck makes it extra cute, but the decorations are up to you!

It warms my heart that this is a tradition I get to continue. And, I think it’s safe to say my daughter enjoys it too!

daughter enjoying lamb cake
My daughter enjoying the lamb cake
And here’s me enjoying the lamb cake when I was my daughter’s age. It’s a family tradition!

This article was first posted March 2020.

‘****

lindsay lehman petersLindsay Lehman Peters is the granddaughter of Founder Jay Lehman and daughter of President Galen Lehman. She lives in Kidron with her husband, her daughter, and her two furbabies.

4.5 13 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

17 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Cheryl
Cheryl
2 years ago

Really cute! The recipe looks tasty, too.

art frasik
art frasik
2 years ago

The lamb cake is the cutest thing I every saw!

Gonger
Gonger
2 years ago

What is the temperature to bake the cake?

susan gortva
susan gortva
2 years ago

love using plates or molds, pans, special utensils, even just once a year. it may seem like a waste of space and money, but memories are forever. thank you for reminding me. I just pulled out my rabbit mold, small egg, small bunny face and dozen small rabbit/egg shaped pans.

Susan lusch
Susan lusch
2 years ago

Thank you for the tooth pick idea! I’ve often tried to insert a straw or skewer to hold the head with mixed results.

Becky
Becky
2 years ago

I have my mom’s old Griswold lamb mold with original recipe. I made it once, when I inherited it a few years ago, and agree about it looking better as a decoration, than it tasted. After seeing this article, I am planning on trying your recipe, when my grandkids come for Easter this year. Thanks!

Karen
Karen
2 years ago

My mom used to make an Easter lamb cake for us every year when I was a child (1970’s).

Mary
Mary
2 years ago

This is so cute. Always wondered how to keep it upright, good ideas. How can I save this recipe for another time? Thank you

Mary
Mary
2 years ago

How can I save a seasonal recipe to use later

Mary
Mary
2 years ago

Will you please save this recipe into a video for future use?

trackback
1 year ago

[…] Old-Fashioned Easter Feast Menu: Classic Leg of Lamb Mommy’s Special Ham Make-Ahead Penne Primavera Salad of Many Colors Parsley Buttered Potatoes Traditional Harvard Beets Fancy Green Beans Lamb Cake […]

trackback
1 year ago

[…] year, we are excited to try the cake recipe and maybe we’ll give this one another go. We will be enjoying the practice runs as many times as […]

Terry
Terry
1 year ago

i have my grandmothers cast iron mold. I remember being told to be careful when eating this cake, because the head would always fall off and she would put toothpicks in it to help hold the head on :).

Lisa
Lisa
3 months ago

I grew up Slovak and this was a tradition at grandma’s and I have my grandma’s lamb cake pan. The cake recipe is made by scratch from an old Slovak recipe book that is delicious. I have the pan and recipe book, and do make it for Easter on occasion.

Lehman's
Lehman's
Admin
Reply to  Lisa
3 months ago

Thank you for sharing, Lisa!

HUGH KAVANAGH
HUGH KAVANAGH
2 months ago

A beloved childhood memory, so many cake molds Mom had my dad make. The memories my Mother and Dad created for us. God rest their souls.

Share lehman's
Facebook
Twitter

also by this author

Newsletter

Lehman’s loves to help folks lead a simpler life.  Submit your email address below, and we’ll send new recipes, simple living tips, and announcements to you.

Follow Us

people also enjoyed reading