Should Lehman’s be buying from China?

Posted by Galen Lehman, President, Lehman’s

A great struggle for me is what to do about merchandise that is made in China.
At Lehman’s, we have had a simple policy: We will not displace a USA vendor with a Chinese vendor. But what started out as a simple concept turned out not to be so simple.

Problem #1
Last week my sister Glenda passed a customer in our Kidron store who was holding a piece of American-made pottery. As she passed, she distinctly heard him say,  I can buy this for half that price at Wal-mart. She knows our products well enough to know for sure that the Wal-mart version was made in China.

What should we do when people accuse Lehman’s of having a high price because we carry American-made products?

Here’s an example: We know you can find a Chinese copy of this USA made camper’s axe for less than $20 at Ace Hardware We also know that the Ace Hardware version is significantly lower quality. Which would you buy?

Problem #2
Recently we received a sample product from a Chinese company. It looked just like an American-made item we carry now. Because of our policy of protecting American vendors, we put the item on a pile of rejected samples that is in our warehouse. A couple weeks later, it was spotted there by one of our telephone customer service representatives, Mark Sutter. He immediately pointed out to me that it had some design improvements that solved customer complaints he had heard about the USA version. Should we protect USA vendors even when we think they are making a low quality product?

Problem #3
There are whole swaths of the American economy that have been decimated by imports. In many product lines, there simply isn’t a single USA manufacturer (that we know of). Here’s some examples:

Sometimes, we carry two versions of the same item, one that is Chinese and one that is American. For example, we carry two toy balloon boats, one that is made by a local Amish woodworker and one that is made in China.

When we carry both the USA-made and imported version of an item, the USA-made version usually sells better. This holds true even though the USA-made version is usually more expensive.

I’d love to hear your responses to these challenges. At Lehman’s, we like to do what our customers want us to do. Do you want USA made items at any price? Would you buy an imported item if you knew it was higher quality than the USA version? Which is best, high quality (at a high price) or quality that is lower but may still be acceptable (at a lower price)?


5 3 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Chad (@chad)
14 years ago

It’s a tough call isn’t it? Speaking for myself, on one hand I want to be frugal, and on the other I don’t want junk. Sometimes its brand recognition. For instance, Do I want a “Snow and Neally” axe or a “Shandong Pangu Tool co.” (real company) axe? In the case of the Snow & Neally axe, it becomes trickier… A quick call to S & N this morning and I now know that the axe head starts in China and is finished here in Maine. What that exactly entails I didn’t completly catch but it was something like, forged in China, tempered and edged here in Maine. The handle of course is American Hickory.
I know I would prefer to just purchase American made products but that’s not realistic. I think it comes down to making informed purchases and buying for what your needs are.

Pat Veretto
Pat Veretto (@pat-veretto)
14 years ago

I don’t know the answer to the quandary about buying quality whether it’s American or not, but I appreciate your effort to offer American made products. Imports may be cheaper, but they cost more in the long run, regardless of quality. The loss of jobs hurts us all.

You said, “What should we do when people accuse Lehman’s of having a high price because we carry American-made products?”

I think you should shrug it off and keep on offering quality American products. Not everyone will agree that’s the best way to go (that’s what makes America what it is), but you can’t please everyone all the time, no matter how hard you try. Better to please those who come looking for quality goods with a realistic price for that quality.

I agree that imports have caused serious damage to our manufacturing base and it’s painful to see.

Elizabeth R
Elizabeth R (@elizabeth-r)
14 years ago

Free trade… fair trade… these are large issues.

On the one hand, I believe in open, free trade, let the best product win. On the other hand, I think we as consumers have a responsibility to not support totalitarian regimes with our purchases. Unlike a union steel worker in the U.S., the Chinese steel worker can’t bargain for better working conditions or higher wages. The Chinese worker can go to prison for professing Christianity, which, in my personal view, is another reason not to support Chinese products, and, thereby, the Chinese government.

I believe “think globally, act locally” is just common sense. I try to buy what little I buy from the most local source I can find. Lehman’s offers goods I can’t find anywhere else, and your reputation is based on the quality of those goods. Therefore, I think you should continue to offer the highest quality you can find, at the lowest price you can offer. If you cannot find an item produced solely in the U.S., but have a customer demand for such an item, then you will be forced to offer the imported goods. It will remain for the consumers to weigh their need for the item against the fact that it is imported.

Is anyone else old enough to remember when having things that were imported from, say, France or England was a matter of snobbery? Or when something marked “Made in Japan” was automatically assumed to be cheaply made and inferior? My, how times change.

WolfBrother (@wolfbrother)
14 years ago

You asked the question – should we carry 2 – one China, one US made.

If you have the storage and funding to allow you to do that, then by all means.

I shop at Walmart but all my axes are gransfor-bruks.
I shop at Walmart but my sleeping bag is a Wiggy’s bag.

I KNOW the quality I’m buying with the G-B axes and Wiggy’s sleeping bags. Then again, a lead fishing weight is a lead fishing weight no matter where it’s made.

And as written above:
I believe “think globally, act locally” is just common sense. I try to buy what little I buy from the most local source I can find. Lehman’s offers goods I can’t find anywhere else, and your reputation is based on the quality of those goods. Therefore, I think you should continue to offer the highest quality you can find, at the lowest price you can offer. If you cannot find an item produced solely in the U.S., but have a customer demand for such an item, then you will be forced to offer the imported goods. It will remain for the consumers to weigh their need for the item against the fact that it is imported.

Greg (@greg)
14 years ago

When faced with the option of purchasing an item “Made in the USA” or “Made in China”, I will pay more to purchase “Made in the USA”. I feel it is better quality and the hidden costs associated with “Made in China” far outweigh the few dollars I may save now. That is one thing that attracted me to Lehman’s and this website initially. With the recent recalls because of lead paint and the “date-rape” drug, Americans got a harsh lesson in this reality that so many choose to ignore for more and cheaper “stuff”. If I can’t find a “Made in the USA” alternative for something I want to purchase, I have to think long and hard about whether or not I really want the item. However, I always thought my books were safe from Chinese domination. I have a pretty extensive personal library of self-sufficiency and gardening/farming books as well as children’s literature and non-fiction for my home school. Imagine my surprise when I purchased a new gardening book by Storey Publishing, brought it home, and discovered “Printed in China” on the title page. After ranting and raving for a few days to everyone who would listen (or even pretend to listen), I finally did what all good Americans do–wrote the company. We’ll see if anything comes of it.

My main disappointment stems from the spirit of Storey publishing–all those books on self-sufficiency and independent thinking. It seems counterintuitive to promote environmentalism while outsourcing your printing. The company’s mission statement is pasted on their website as follows: “To serve our customers by publishing practical information that encourages personal independence in harmony with the environment.” I don’t think it is environmentally harmonious to write books here, print them on the other side of the world in a place where the people are locked into slave-like working conditions and materials are consistently substandard and sometimes hazardous, and then ship them back here to teach people how to live a simple life.

Recently, I was shopping for a book on butterflies. After comparing a book from Storey and one from another publisher, I chose the other publisher because of one statement: “Printed in China”.

Let’s encourage our book publishers and makers of all our goods to go “Made in the USA” in the best way we can–avoid buying anything that says “Made in China”.

Wade (@rjwade)
14 years ago

I think I’m with WolfBrother on this one. Above and beyond scarcity, what it boils down to is quality.

I don’t have a problem paying a little extra upfront when I’m secure in the knowledge that I have a tool or product that will perform as expected- when expected. Whether the tool was made in the US, Canada, China, UK, Germany, or the darkest corner of the Amazon is inconsequential.

Attempting to run down from which countries raw materials might have come from, knowing the manufacturing likely took place in a second, and the actual packaging in a third; feels like a futile exercise.

In respect to Storey Publishing, who I have absolutely no affiliation with, what they do is “content” and that’s their product. If the books are poorly bound, the paper and ink substandard and subject to early degradation- there’s a legitimate gripe that needs to be brought to their attention. I’m sure they don’t want their product line jeopardized by printing quality issues.

Aside: I might be mistaken but I seem recall that paper making and printing were of Chinese invention. Somehow I’d expect them to get it right for no other reason than national pride.

And with that said, I hope Lehman’s continues to offer superior quality products.

Now where did I leave my coffee . . .

9 years ago

[…] wrote about our struggles in 2007 (click here for the article). That posting got me in trouble when our vendor admitted that one of the products I believed was “American-made” […]

Barbara Telfian
Barbara Telfian
5 months ago

I prefer to buy American, although the higher price is sometimes hard to swallow. Can the USA manufactures make things more cost effectively? I’m not sure, but we have to support our fellow citizens. Consume less, or save for the important things we want, which in this fast pace, social media craziness is not always easy.

4 months ago

I look to you for American made/ Time to take care of our own/

4 months ago

I appreciate this topic. Thank you. I work with a man from China. He and his family are a first generation family and speaking with him about China or about Wuhan has been an eye opener. As a result I will be buying as little as possible from Walmart. I will need to buy less since I will be paying more. Im totally fine with that. Look up Nike products and their slave labor conditions that are involved with their products . I will never buy Nike products as a result of taking a little look. I used to ask myself how people historically accepted slavery here in the USA? Now I see how. People ignore what makes them uncomfortable or what effects their pocketbook. People will justify anything on “ inconvenience” alone.
Another source of conversation about china: brief but interesting mention on Youtube. Can Am Missing 411. David Paulides. 12/26/2021. A few minutes- first few minutes in his YouTube presentation- but thoughtfully presented. It made me pause and think about our global interaction with China. Please consider selling products not made in China. Thank you!

Mary Lennox
Mary Lennox
4 months ago

Well it seems as though with this dilemma you may have created a new business opportunity for someone. The fact that you have found a business in a America that cannot find an American Foundry to produce the piece they need. Perhaps the business opportunity is for a web site or circle of productivty that is pushed through the lines of business communication to find a US company for the product they need and/or perhaps even someone maybe willing to start a company based on the need.
America, the land of opportunity, is still here we may just have to start communication lines to find those opportunities, kinda like the old days when neighbors actually spoke to their neighbors.

Charles Reid
Charles Reid
3 months ago

I for one , and sure that I’m not alone that I would rather pay more for a made in the “U.S.A.” than a china import as I don’t live in that country or like having to buy their poor quality merchandise with no choice available to me !

3 months ago

I for one have stopped buying poor quality items, especially things like clothing or linens, where not only poor materials are used, but they save money by short changing materials like to short or to tight sleeves, or sheets that don’t fit or has elastic that never last.
I guess you catch my meaning….I would be happy with one well made item, and, willing to pay for it…. then to waste my hard earned money on inferior products. This has also helped me downsize my life. A win win situation ;)

Kimberly Cochran
Kimberly Cochran
3 months ago

You get what you pay for.
As for China having better quality I would talk to the American vendor and explain the situation and try to work out the improvements that needs to be made.

Sandra Kaiser
Sandra Kaiser
2 months ago

I believe that the “thinking globally” slogan is what’s got us into a situation that would be devastating for the country if China were to stop trading with us. That might have sounded impossible a couple of years ago but with the state of the world now, anything could happen. I think we need to think AND act locally to preserve our nation. Buy American unless you have no other choice. Doing without and living more frugally IS a choice we can re-learn.

David Peterman
David Peterman
1 month ago

You would be better off buying from any country that is our ally, China is not our Ally. If I can’t find it made in America, I will buy from any of the following countries, England, Italy, Germany, Hungary, Netherlands, Australia, Sweden, Poland, Switzerland, Spain. So think about that.

Debra L Sifers
Debra L Sifers
1 month ago

Yes please I would much rather pay more for something, knowing that the quality is good and and purchasing USA is providing jobs for Americans. We have come to depend entirely too much on imports, for example look at our oil imports from Russia. .If Russia and China would come together in the Ukraine situation and we stopped receiving products made in China for which we depend on every day,we are really going to be hurting.We need to reopen factories and put people back to work, making the products that our grandparents and parents used..and buy the way..I am still using alot of those things that gave survived the test if time and their usefulness. When I purchase something I always feel a sense of pride when I see that stamp made in the USA.

Share lehman's
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on pocket
Share on whatsapp
Share on telegram
Share on stumbleupon

also by this author


Lehman’s loves to help folks lead a simpler life.  Submit your email address below, and we’ll send new recipes, simple living tips, and announcements to you.

people also enjoyed reading