From Amish Country, With Love: Handmade Chocolates for Your Valentine

chocolate sea salt caramels

I won’t beat around the bush: when it comes to Valentine’s Day, it just has to be chocolate. Am I right? Even the most painstakingly chosen gift adorned in fancy trimmings isn’t nearly as sweet without some chocolate-y goodness to go with it. And we’re all in luck this year, because Lehman’s is offering some of the choicest chocolates made in Ohio’s Amish Country, delivered directly to your doorstep. It’s a sweet tooth’s dream. Let’s take a little tour, shall we?

Um...yeah, that is real butter. A LOT of real butter.
Um…yeah, that is real butter. A LOT of real butter.

Our chocolate journey begins at a family-owned chocolate factory deep in Amish Country. And yes, that is real butter in the photo above. Lots and LOTS of real butter. Yep, this is farm country all right! And only the best and freshest ingredients will do for your Valentine (and you).

2015-09-18 08.40.51

The small company employs many Amish ladies who, armed with the stellar kitchen skills their community is known for, turn out dozens of varieties of sweet confections that keep people coming back for more, and more, and more. Above, ingredients are added to the giant copper kettle, which mixes them into smooth, buttery caramel

2015-09-18 08.42.57

which is then spread out, the old-fashioned way, completely by hand.

2015-09-18 08.43.19

After the caramels are shaped and cut…

2015-09-18 08.34.02

they’re ready to be covered with sweet milk chocolate or rich dark chocolate, then hand-sprinkled with fine sea salt for the ultimate finishing touch. (I recently took an entire box of these chocolates to a gathering of friends … and I wasn’t fast enough to get a single one. Luckily, I know where to get more.)

2015-09-18 08.34.39

If your Valentine’s not the caramel type, he or she might like to try a chocolate road apple. Crunchy peanut butter, crispy rice and marshmallows are coated with rich milk chocolate and affectionately named after the “apples” we dodge at times, since we share the roads with horse-drawn buggies and wagons.

Our chocolate road apples are the delicious, edible kind! A fun, yummy gift for anyone. At

And, for those who don’t like chocolate (because we DO realize those people exist, which means more chocolate for us…), delight them with our soft, hand-wrapped caramels, made with or without a dash of sea salt. They are not as good as homemade…they are EVEN BETTER because the work is done for you! They’re simply divine.


And now, back to the chocolate…

Our very own, exclusive Chocolate Potato Chip Caramel Corn. It’s a doozy of a treat! And you won’t find it anywhere else.

We invented the concoction above, and we have to admit, we’re pretty proud of it. Locally made caramel popcorn is mixed with crunched-up pieces of our best-selling (and also locally made) Gold’N Krisp potato chips, and THEN drizzled with smooth milk chocolate. Sweet and salty never tasted so good!  (It’s also on sale just in time for Valentine’s Day.)

And finally, if your Valentine is an Ohio State fan (or just a chocolate-peanut butter fan), for goodness’ sake, get him/her some BUCKEYES! Happy Valentine’s Day from Amish Country!

Creamy peanut butter fudge covered in rich milk chocolate – it’s our state’s favorite handmade treat! Enjoy some buckeyes wherever you live (and whomever you root for). At and our store in Kidron, Ohio.

Shop MORE Sweet and Treats from Lehman’s >>

Chocolate factory photos by Bruce Stambaugh.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Share lehman's

also by this author

The Wanderer

Here’s a great article from our archives by C.J. Mouser. She writes from her farm in central Florida, where she raises swine and grows oranges

Read More


Lehman’s loves to help folks lead a simpler life.  Submit your email address below, and we’ll send new recipes, simple living tips, and announcements to you.

Recent News

Follow Us

people also enjoyed reading